That Old Pyrex Dish in Your Grandmother’s Cabinet Could Be Worth $4,000

A 1959 Pyrex one-quart Cinderella casserole in the rare Lucky in Love pattern has sold for over $4,000 on eBay, far above the $15–$45 that most vintage Pyrex pieces command. The Corning Museum of Glass’s Pyrex Potluck archive lists the design among the most elusive patterns, and PyrexVault corroborates its scarcity. The sale highlights how pattern rarity can drive extreme price dispersion in the collectibles market. Collectors will be watching whether other scarce patterns post similar four-figure results or whether this remains an isolated outlier.